The Most Beautiful Old Houses on the Market Right Now

A curated collection of the best old houses for sale đź’›

c. 1870

Incredible Second Empire Residence

Flemington, New Jersey | $784,900

Why settle for ordinary, when you can have extraordinary! This distinctive circa-19th Century Second Empire Victorian residence in Flemington Borough, is a standout in the community. It’s renowned convex mansard roof, dormers and central roof detail, and massive indoor wraparound porch create memorable curb appeal with a welcoming touch. Historic features continue inside with a handsome wood staircase featuring turned wood balusters and decorative scroll-cut brackets, decorative ceiling medallions, high ceilings and gracious traditional rooms, including a formal dining room with original medallion. The current owners have renovated many spaces, including kitchens, bathrooms, bedrooms, and built-ins – With a detached garage, rear parking and a versatile layout, this property offers endless possibilities – Residential living and potential income producing use. Enjoy the convenience and character of Flemington’s Main Street setting. 

c. 1974

Creekside Mid-Century
Gainesville, FL - $1.4 mil

c. 1855

Finger Lakes Victorian
Geneva, NY - $849,900

c. 1789

Idyllic New England
Goffstown, NH - $499,900

c. 1880

Exquisitely Restored
Cooperstown, TN - $1.1 mil

c. 1903

The John R. Toole House

Missoula, Montana | $2,600,000

The John R. Toole House is a National Register–listed historic property offering a compelling adaptive reuse opportunity in Missoula’s University District. The building totals approximately ±13,977 square feet above grade with an additional ±4,898 square feet of below-grade space, providing flexibility for a range of redevelopment concepts. The property’s historic designation makes it eligible for the Federal 20% Historic Tax Credit and Montana’s 5% Historic Tax Credit. With these, a buyer can potentially offset up to 25% of qualified rehabilitation costs and materially improve redevelopment economics. Combined with the property’s quiet neighborhood setting, historic character, and adopted U-R4 zoning, which allows a broad range of uses by right, the asset offers a rare opportunity to reposition a legacy property while preserving its architectural and historical significance.


c. 1820

Built for Town Namesake!
Paden City, WV - $285,000

c. 1900

Waterfront Sanctuary
Essex, CT - $2.85 mil

c. 1908

Stately on 17+ Acres
Brooklyn, NY - $899,000

c. 1855

Former Parsonage Gem
Smyrna, DE - $375,000

Looking For Cheaper?

You need our Cheap Old Houses Newsletters.

Here's an insane house we sent to subscribers this week.

Sign up for free to receive notifications of the best cheap houses around:

c. 1742

The Minshall-Green House

Media, Pennsylvania | $1,375,000

The Minshall–Green house is a remarkable property, tucked away from the crowds yet convenient to so many things. This solid masonry residence has the kind of curb appeal that magazines cherish (and so would you!). From the sidewalk, the house is perfectly sited on the expansive grounds, one of the larger lots in the neighborhood. The staircase is a beautiful focal point (with a coat closet underneath), as is the corner wood burning fireplace. The original woods floors are in excellent condition, and there are multiple windows that provide great views. There is a large four-season sunroom along the entire southern side of the living room, with direct access to the front and rear yards. In just 15-20 minutes, one can get to the Philadelphia International Airport or Newtown Square with shops & restaurants.

c. 1929

Former Hospital Estate
Tryon, NC - $895,000

c. 1880

Central Location Gem
Glen Ridge, NJ - $1.429 mil

c. 1856

Calico Estate
Lenoir, NC - $1.25 mil

c. 1905

Timeless Details
Worcester, MA - $399,900

c. 1860

Rural Retreat 3.5 Acres
Canajoharie, NY - $389,900

c. 1920

Historic Carriage House
Amsterdam, NY - $359,900

c. 1850

South Mountain Log House
Burkittsville, MD - $275,000

c. 1850

Original Features 2+ Acres
Chesapeake, VA - $875,000

c. 1830

Farmhouse on 5+ Acres
Wrightstown, PA - $1.05 mil

c. 1917

Park Circle Charmer
North Charleston, SC - $799,900

c. 1920

Classic Foursquare
Springfield, KY - $269,900

c. 1921

Country Home on Acre
Sparta, TN - $424,500

Black Friday Starts… Now!

Take 40% off eligible shop items for the next 48 hours.


Yes, that includes the Cheap Old Houses book!

And we’ll tuck in a FREE Cheap Old House Fund coin pouch + stickers w/your purchase.