The Most Beautiful Old Houses on the Market This Week

A curated collection of the best old houses for sale 💛

c. 1862

Rare Hudson Valley Residence

Newburgh, New York | $699,000

An exquisitely restored and fully furnished architectural treasure believed to have been built in 1862 for Sylvanus Thayer—an early superintendent of West Point—this rare Hudson Valley residence blends history, pedigree, and beautifully considered design. Meticulously reimagined with a reverence for timeless materials, the home offers soaring ceilings, tall original windows, museum-grade marble fireplaces, refined millwork, and wide-plank floors with rich patina.

c. 1915

Idyllic Victorian
Mt. Kisco, NY - $1.25 mil

c. 1910

The Kingsbury-Curtis House
Tuxedo Park, NY - $5.95 mil

c. 1907

Converted Power Plant
Silver Spring, MD - $659,000

c. 1913

The William Dunn Sr. House
New Bern, NC - $995,000

Looking For Something Cheaper?

You need our Cheap Old Houses Newsletters.

Here's an insane house we sent to subscribers this week:

We scour the market to hand-pick the best houses at rock-bottom prices. Then, we send them to your inbox so you can do the rest!

Try all 4 weekly newsletters for a whole month - for just $1!

CODE: 1DOLLAR

Subscription for all 4 newsletters $12 per month after first month $1 promotion

c. 1755

The Sloat House

Sloatsburg, New York | $995,000

Once the Sloat House & Inn, this gem was originally built in 1755 and served as a command post. Operated by the Sloat family, the inn offered lodging and meals to the Continental Troops, including General George Washington. Understandably, the property has earned its place on the National Register of Historic Places. This authentic exquisite home is now available for the first time in over 40 years. Lovingly maintained and updated but retaining all of the historic elements that catches everyone’s attention and imagination no matter how often you see it - this one is special!


c. 1822

Ridgecrest
Lynchburg, VA - $1.6 mil

c. 1870

Classic Charm
Oswego, NY - $349,000

c. 1927

Dreamy Tudor Cottage
Molalla, OR - $750,000

c. 1840

Heritage Farmhouse
Trumansburg, NY - $489,500

c. 1740

Updated Antique Farmhouse

Westford, Massachusetts | $1,699,000

Set on a picturesque 1.63-acre parcel in the heart of Westford Center, this inviting home has been thoughtfully updated to support today’s lifestyle while preserving its inherent charm. Light-filled living spaces with tall ceilings and exposed wood beams create an open, comfortable feel, while more traditional rooms offer flexibility for entertaining, work, or quiet downtime. Recent improvements include updated systems, windows, roof, and a newly finished third-floor bonus space—ideal for a home office, hangout area, or guest suite. Outdoor living is equally appealing, with a three-season porch for casual dining, a patio with fire pit, and an expansive yard for recreation. Just steps from Westford Center, enjoy easy access to the farmer’s market, library, playgrounds, local shops, and year-round community events.

c. 1875

Landmark Restoration
Prince Edward Co., Ontario - $2,199,900

c. 1798

East Hill Farm on 227 Acres
New Marlborough, MA - $4.995 mil

c. 1911

Hyde Park Masterpiece
Kansas City, MO - $825,000

c. 1850

The Wilda Farmhouse
Prince Edward Co., Ontario - $1.85 mil

c. 1915

Converted Carnegie Library
Fullerton, NE - $397,000

c. 1860

Idyllic New England
Lexington, MA - $2.15 mil

c. 1880

Stunning Italianate
Peekskill, NY - $899,900

c. 1848

Greek Revival Mansion
Milan, OH - Auction

c. 1791

Reimagined Church Residence
Plymouth, MA, ME - $599,999

c. 1920

Landmark Estate
Tarpon Springs, FL - $1.625 mil

c. 1890

Colonial Revival Sparkler
Pittsburgh, PA - $1.2 mil

c. 1975

Lake & Mountain Views
Littleton, CO - $629,900

c. 1820

Restored Federal Manor
Plymouth Meeting, PA - $769,000

c. 1795

Spring Hill Farm
Barnard, VT - $2.195 mil

c. 1910

Camp Woods
Villanova, PA - $5.499 mil

c. 1929

Colonial Revival Classic
Corning, NY - $479,000

c. 1923

Oasis Craftsman Bungalow
Pasadena, CA - $989,000

c. 1840

Stately Italianate Near NYC
Chesterfield, NJ - $999,999

c. 1900

Notable Architect + Curb Appeal
Cleveland Heights, OH - $450,000

c. 1870

5 Bedroom Victorian Charm
Cambridge, NY - $360,000

Our Shop is For Old House Lovers!