c. 1780
Mill House & Restored Chapel on 2 Acres
East Haddam, Connecticut | $749,000
Rare opportunity in the Hadlyme section of East Haddam featuring two dwellings on one parcel set in a scenic, natural setting. The main circa 1780 Mill House offers approximately 1,786 sq ft with original hardwood floors, chestnut paneling, two second-floor bedrooms, two additional attic rooms, and a first-floor suite with fireplace and private entrance overlooking a historic spring-fed pond. Central air, oil heat, and recent hot water heater. The second dwelling is the thoughtfully restored Grace Chapel (circa 1901), now a modern ADU featuring an open layout with one bedroom, one and a half baths, full kitchen, and mudroom.
c. 1864Eufaula House B&BEufaula, AL - $650,000 | c. 1840Italianate on 2+ AcresChesterfield, NJ - $1.1 mil |
c. 1903Foursquare BeautyOcala, FL - $899,000 | c. 1890The Hattie Ford HouseBeaufort, SC - $1.695 mil |
Looking For Something Cheaper?
You need our Cheap Old Houses Newsletters.
Here's an insane house we sent to subscribers this week:
We scour the market to hand-pick the best houses at rock-bottom prices. Then, we send them to your inbox so you can do the rest!
Try all 4 weekly newsletters for a whole month - for just $1!
Subscription for all 4 newsletters $12 per month after first month $1 promotion
c. 1740Own a Piece of History!Mount Sinai, FL - $925,000 | c. 1875Fabulous Greek RevivalBelfast, ME - $679,000 |
c. 1867Italianate Manor on 3+ AcresEufaula, AL - $2.5 mil | c. 1910The Grey LadyAmericus, GA - $499,000 |
c. 1880
The Most Gorgeous Woodwork!
St. Joseph, Missouri | $749,900
This one-of-a-kind home sits on a double lot along a desirable, tree-lined street in historic St. Joseph, Missouri. Originally designed and built by renowned architect Edmond J. Eckel, this timeless residence showcases the craftsmanship and character you simply canโt replicate. Youโll be in awe of original stained glass and intricate woodwork, working transoms, embossed tin ceilings, and two elegant staircases. Step outside to your own private retreat. The large, fenced backyard includes an in-ground pool with a recently replaced pump and liner, mature landscaping, and an underground sprinkler system. A two-car detached garage and ample off-street parking provide added convenience.
c. 1900Retreat in Heart of Town Virginia City, MT - $445,000 | c. 1920Spanish-Style GemPalmetto, FL - $399,000 |
c. 1938English Brick HomeLumberton, NC - $187,500 | c. 1860Second Empire on 2+ AcresBrunswick, MO - $295,000 |
c. 1815
Historic Estate on Over 6 Acres
Greensburg, Kentucky | $395,000
Proudly listed on both the Federal and State Historical Home Registries. Set on 6.27 unrestricted acres within the city limits, this rare opportunity blends preserved character with modern updates and endless potential. Offering 2,872 square feet, the home features 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, along with updates including central heat and air and updated electrical, providing todayโs comfort while maintaining its historic charm. The expansive acreage allows for livestock with no restrictions, a true rarity for an intown property. Adding to its appeal is a detached one-car garage with living quarters above, ideal for guest accommodations, rental income, or on-site management. With its setting, acreage, and architectural significance, this property presents an excellent investment opportunity for a venue, event space, or unique short-term rental.
c. 1890Beautiful Details & Large LotGonzales, TX - $355,000 | c. 1930Cul-de-Sac Colonial RevivalMaplewood, NJ - $1.479 mil |
c. 1950Colonial Revival MansionHazlehurst, MS - $489,000 | c. 1911Classic Victorian CharmWashington, IN - $295,000 |

Our founder (and Preservation Expert!) Elizabeth Finkelstein, weighs in on old house features always worth saving.